Skills-Based Hiring: How to Put It Into Practice

Dropping a degree requirement changes little until intake, screening and sourcing change too

A recruiter and hiring manager discuss a job requirements document at a wood meeting-room table during an intake meeting

Skills-based hiring means choosing candidates on the skills a job needs, shown through evidence, instead of proxies like degrees or GPAs.

For a recruiter, that moves the work into the intake call, the search, and the screen. Get those right and you reach a wider pool the hiring manager or client can trust.

Key takeaways

  • Dropping a degree requirement on paper barely changes who gets hired.
  • Replace the degree at intake with must-have skills and the evidence for each one.
  • Search on skills and tools, and leave degree filters off unless the work needs the credential.
  • Treat a degree requirement like a test: both are selection procedures, so track pass rates by group.

What skills-based hiring is

Adoption is growing among employers that hire new college graduates. In NACE's Job Outlook 2026 survey, 70% of them report using skills-based hiring, up from 65% the year before.

The U.S. Chamber Foundation describes it as a process run by employers and their HR service providers. That makes it agency and independent recruiter work as much as an HR policy.

Skills-based vs. degree-based hiring

The two approaches differ at every stage.

StageSkills-basedDegree-based
What the opening asks forMust-have skillsA degree plus years of experience
What the screen looks forEvidence of the workSchool and GPA and job titles
How skills get checkedWork sample and structured interview with a rubricInterviews not tied to a skills rubric
Where you sourceSkills and tools plus other training routesDegree and school filters
How the decision gets madeScored against the same skillsCredentials and title history

Why dropping the degree requirement isn't enough

Removing "bachelor's required" from a posting changes very little on its own. A Harvard Business School study found that fewer than 1 in 700 new hires benefited from no-degree reforms. The same study reviewed more than 11,000 U.S. job postings from 2014 to 2023. Hiring of non-degree candidates rose just 3.5 percentage points.

Joseph Fuller, who led the study, says companies have to do far more than rewrite postings. The change happens where a recruiter works: the intake, the search, the screen, and the final decision.

Turn the degree requirement into skills at intake

At the intake call, ask the hiring manager or client what the degree stands in for, then list the tasks it's meant to predict. The Chamber Foundation notes employers are starting to ask for only their most critical skills while reducing their use of indirect signals like degrees and work experience.

Under the federal Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, education and experience requirements count as selection procedures, just like tests. The job-related section below explains what that means for a degree requirement.

For each must-have skill, agree on the evidence that proves it: a work sample, a portfolio, a license, or a structured interview answer. Write those into the ideal candidate profile so everyone screens against the same list.

  • Outcomes: ask what this person will deliver in the first year.
  • Tie-breaker: ask whether the degree would change the pick between two finalists who can both do that.
  • Teachable skills: ask which skills the team could teach in the first week, and move those off the must-have list.

Settle buy-in before anyone screens. Fuller notes that hiring managers want someone who will do well right away, because that affects their own performance and credibility. So give them evidence they can weigh:

  • Scorecard first: agree on the scorecard before the first screen.
  • Expert role: ask the hiring manager to help build the work sample.
  • Pilot: try the approach on one open role before you roll it out.

Example: a degree requirement turned into skills

Say a payroll specialist opening asks for a bachelor's degree in accounting and several years of experience. After intake, the must-haves become skills you can see in the work:

  • Runs multi-state payroll in the current system.
  • Reconciles payroll to the general ledger.
  • Explains pay questions to employees clearly.

The evidence is a short reconciliation exercise and a structured interview question about a past pay error.

Rewrite the job post around skills

A skills-first job post leads with the work and lists only the must-have skills from intake. Among employers that hire new college graduates in the NACE survey, 81% use skills-based practices when creating job descriptions.

  • Degree line: drop "bachelor's required" where intake replaced it, or add "or equivalent experience" and define what counts.
  • Routes that count: name community college, bootcamps, certificate programs, military service, and on-the-job learning.
  • Assessment: tell candidates how their skills will be checked.

A clear job description also gives the screen its scoring list, since each skill becomes one line on the scorecard.

Before you use a degree filter, check who it misses

A degree or school filter drops qualified people from your search before anyone reads their profile. The U.S. Chamber Foundation reports that more than 70 million U.S. adults are skilled through routes other than a bachelor's degree. Those routes include community college, workforce training, bootcamps, certificate programs, military service, and on-the-job learning.

Skills-based recruitment starts with how you build the search:

  • Search terms: build it from the intake skills, including tasks, tools, certifications, and projects.
  • Titles: try adjacent job titles that involve the same tasks, and add the words candidates use for that work.
  • Filters: drop degree and school filters unless the credential is required to do the work.
  • Sources: reach out through apprenticeship programs, community colleges, and military transition programs.

Search on skills, not degree filters

Book a demo

Screen and assess for evidence of skills

Screen for proof that a candidate has done the work, then confirm it with a short task and a structured interview. The same graduate employers in NACE's survey use skills-based hiring most often in interviewing (87%) and screening (65%), and 58% use it in interview rubrics.

  • Resume screen: look for what the person built, ran, or fixed, and with which tools.
  • Work sample: use one short task tied to a real part of the job, like a ticket reply for a support role.
  • Interview: ask every candidate the same questions and score answers on a shared rubric. Our structured interview guide shows how to write them.

What federal hiring now prefers

Federal hiring is moving the same way. The Chance to Compete Act of 2024 aims to replace degree-based hiring with skills- and competency-based hiring in the federal civil service.

Under the law, agencies favor technical assessments to the maximum extent practicable. As the law defines it, a technical assessment lets candidates demonstrate job-related skills and is based on a job analysis. It also can't solely or principally rely on a self-assessment from an automated examination, so don't accept self-ratings as evidence either. The law covers civil service hiring, but it shows what a credible skills check looks like.

The Uniform Guidelines don't require validity studies where no adverse impact results. But a screen with adverse impact is considered discriminatory unless it has been validated or meets the guidelines' other conditions.

So track every screen's pass rates by race, sex, and ethnic group, including a degree requirement. A pass rate less than four-fifths (80%) of the highest group's rate will generally be regarded by the Federal enforcement agencies as evidence of adverse impact. The guidelines also set standards you can build in:

  • Job analysis: build each assessment from a review of the job's tasks.
  • Cutoff scores: set them at a level of acceptable proficiency for the role.
  • Retesting: give candidates a reasonable chance at retesting and reconsideration.
  • Bought tests: if you buy a test from a vendor, you're still responsible for compliance.

If a client asks you to design and run a screen, you should follow the guidelines' standards for determining adverse impact. The client keeps its own obligations either way. Our pre-employment assessments guide compares test formats you can match to each skill.

Make the case to the hiring manager or client

Lead the pitch with results. The HBS study found that at companies leading in skills-based hiring, non-degree hires had retention 10 percentage points higher than colleagues with degrees.

Then show finalists side by side with the evidence for each must-have skill. For agency recruiters, pitch it as a wider pool plus evidence the client sees before the interview. Start this week by asking at your next intake what the degree is standing in for.

Frequently asked questions

Can a candidate who fails a skills assessment still be hired?

Yes, depending on how much the test counts in the decision. Cutoff scores should reflect acceptable proficiency, and candidates should get a reasonable chance at retesting and reconsideration.

What is a skill-based job?

A skill-based job is any role filled on demonstrated skills instead of credentials. It's easiest to start where the work can be sampled, such as payroll, customer support, or software development.

Is skills-based recruitment the same as skills-based hiring?

Not quite, since recruitment is the attract-and-source side: skills-first job posts and searches without degree filters. Hiring adds the screen, the assessment, and the decision.

About the author

Mihailo Bozic
Mihailo Bozic

Founder & CEO @ Rotto

Founder & CEO of Rotto, building tools that help tech recruiters source better candidates, faster.

Related articles

How to Use AI in Your ATS
Recruiter Playbooks

How to Use AI in Your ATS

Use AI in your ATS without missing good candidates: start with features a recruiter reviews, then test ranking on a role you have already filled.

By Mihailo Bozic
Campus Recruiting: How to Plan a Season That Ends in Hires
Recruiter Playbooks

Campus Recruiting: How to Plan a Season That Ends in Hires

Plan campus recruiting from school choice to start date: pick schools, set offer deadlines schools accept, track intern conversion, and know agency rules.

By Mihailo Bozic
AI Recruiting: A Practical Guide for Recruiters
Hiring TrendsRecruiter Playbooks

AI Recruiting: A Practical Guide for Recruiters

AI recruiting explained for working recruiters: what AI does at each hiring stage, the risks, the U.S. rules to know, and how to start safely.

By Mihailo Bozic
B2B Technographic Data: A Practical Guide for Recruiters
Recruiter Playbooks

B2B Technographic Data: A Practical Guide for Recruiters

Learn what B2B technographic data shows, how providers collect it, and how recruiters can use it for business development, sourcing, and vetting providers.

By Mihailo Bozic
Candidate Data: What It Includes and How Recruiters Use It
Recruiter Playbooks

Candidate Data: What It Includes and How Recruiters Use It

Learn what candidate data includes, six practical ways to use it in recruiting, and how to keep your candidate records accurate, fair, and lawful.

By Mihailo Bozic
9-Box Grid: What It Is, How to Run One, and What It Means for Hiring
Recruiter Playbooks

9-Box Grid: What It Is, How to Run One, and What It Means for Hiring

Learn what a 9-box grid is, what each box means, how to run a fair 9-box talent review, and how to turn the gaps it shows into a hiring plan.

By Mihailo Bozic
Rotto

Built for recruiters who work from a brief, not a boolean.

rotto.com