New Hire Feedback: Check-In Questions, Examples, and a Worksheet

What to ask new hires and their managers in the first 90 days, what useful feedback sounds like in both directions, and how to use the answers in the next search

Written by Mihailo Bozic
A recruiter takes handwritten notes while a new hire speaks candidly at a warm café table

When a hire starts, new hire feedback tells a recruiter whether the job matches what the search promised. Once the offer is signed, attention moves to the next opening, and the recruiter can lose sight of how the person is settling in.

New hire feedback is the two-way exchange in a new employee's first months. The new hire describes the role, onboarding, and hiring process, and the manager describes how the hire is settling in. For a recruiter, those answers show whether the search described the job accurately, catch problems while they're fixable, and improve the next intake conversation.

Key takeaways

  • Schedule check-ins for the first week, day 30, day 60, and day 90, and give each one a clear purpose.
  • Ask the new hire and the hiring manager or client separate questions at each check-in, then compare the answers.
  • Give and relay feedback that names a specific moment in the work and what to do next time.
  • Sort what you hear into role description, onboarding, and manager relationship issues, and send each to the right person.

What new hire feedback covers and why recruiters collect it

New hire feedback covers both the new hire's view of the role and onboarding and the manager's view of their progress. Managers and HR teams use it to track engagement and early performance. A recruiter listens for whether the job description was accurate and the interviews gave a fair picture of the work.

The U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM), the federal government's human resources agency, offers useful timing advice. Its talent management guidance says new hire surveys should be given during an employee's first 90 days. It describes them as a source of data on how the person is adjusting and engaging in the new role. The guidance is written for federal agencies, but the timing is a reasonable starting point elsewhere.

When to collect new hire feedback: a check-in schedule

A workable schedule spreads check-ins across the first 90 days, with a different purpose at each point. Early-tenure employees are a sizable group. In January 2026, 20.6% of U.S. wage and salary workers had been with their employer a year or less, BLS tenure data shows.

  • First week: Confirm the basics are in place, such as equipment, system access, and a first assignment, so setup problems get caught early.
  • Day 30: Compare the role with how it was described during hiring, now that the new hire has seen enough daily work to notice differences.
  • Day 60: Check that the new hire knows how their work will be judged, and invite pay, schedule, or workload concerns while they can still be adjusted.
  • Day 90: Look back on the whole hire, including what should change in the job description and what the next search for this role should do differently.

Who runs each check-in depends on the setting. In-house, the recruiter may handle the first week and day 30, then hand later conversations to the hiring manager or HR. The recruiter still collects what affects future searches.

For agency recruiters, the schedule can line up with the guarantee period. Agree with the client on who contacts the new hire and when, so the person doesn't get mixed messages from both sides.

New hire survey questions to ask at each check-in

New hire survey questions work best when each one points to something you can act on. The set should change as the new hire learns more about the job, and the questions below follow the same stages as the worksheet.

  • First week: "Did you have what you needed to start work?" and "Is anything different from what you expected?"
  • Day 30: "How does the role compare with how it was described?" and "What would make the next month easier?"
  • Day 60: "Do you know how your work will be judged?" and "Anything about schedule, pay or workload to raise?"
  • Day 90: "What should change in the job description?" and "Would you recommend this role to a friend?"

At day 30, a short rating question gives you something to compare across hires. Ask the new hire to rate "The role matches what I was told in the hiring process" on a 1 to 5 scale. Follow it with an open question about what's different, since the score shows that something changed but not what to fix.

A short call can draw out more candid onboarding feedback than a form, though a brief form suits high-volume placements. Either way, tell the new hire who will see the answers, and keep the questions open rather than leading, as in "You're enjoying the team, right?"

Someone a few weeks into a job may hesitate to criticize a new employer, so expect some caution early on. Keep the topics to the work, and stay away from health, family plans, and other personal matters.

Questions to ask the hiring manager or client

The hiring manager or client sees the hire from the other side, so their questions focus on progress and support. Asking both sides at the same check-in shows where their views differ.

  • First week: "Are setup or access issues slowing them down?"
  • Day 30: "What is going well, and what should they focus on next?"
  • Day 60: "Is progress where you expected at this point?"
  • Day 90: "What should the next search for this role do differently?"

The day 90 answer can be especially useful for a recruiter, because the manager can now name skills the role needed that the job description left out. If you track quality of hire, these conversations also give you the manager's view to record alongside other measures.

New hire feedback examples in both directions

Feedback in a new hire's first months runs both ways. It comes from the new hire to you, and from the manager to the new hire.

When feedback comes from the new hire, sort the issue by type and decide who should hear about it.

  • "The on-call schedule is heavier than I expected": Check what the job description and interviews said about on-call work. Raise it with the manager, and update the intake notes so the next candidate hears an accurate description.
  • "I still don't have access to the systems I need": This is an onboarding issue rather than a role problem, so pass it to the manager or HR with the specific systems named.

Feedback to a new hire helps most when it's tied to a moment in the work, balanced, and focused on what to do next. A manager or recruiter can reword vague comments before they're shared.

  • Speaking up: Vague: "You need to speak up more." Specific: "In Tuesday's client call, you had the numbers the team needed. Next time, share them when the budget question comes up."
  • Pace of work: Vague: "You're a bit slow." Specific: "Your first reports needed extra rounds of edits. Let's agree on the format before you start the next one."
  • Positive feedback: Vague: "Great job this week." Specific: "Your notes from the vendor meeting meant nobody had to follow up for details."

When you relay a client's comments as an agency recruiter, keep the wording neutral and close to what the client said. Leave out personality judgments such as "not a team player," which give the new hire nothing to change. The principles behind useful interview feedback apply here too, except that the person hearing it now works alongside the person giving it.

A new hire feedback worksheet you can copy

The worksheet puts each check-in's questions for the new hire and the manager on one page, with space for notes. Download it, or copy the text version below into your own notes or form.

  • Header fields: New hire, Role, Start date, Hiring manager or client, Recruiter
  • First week, ask the new hire: "Did you have what you needed to start work?" "Is anything different from what you expected?" Optional: "Who do you go to with questions?"
  • First week, ask the manager or client: "Are setup or access issues slowing them down?"
  • Day 30 rating: "Role matches what I was told: 1 2 3 4 5"
  • Day 30, ask the new hire: "How does the role compare with how it was described?" "What would make the next month easier?"
  • Day 30, ask the manager or client: "What is going well, and what should they focus on next?"
  • Day 60, ask the new hire: "Do you know how your work will be judged?" "Anything about schedule, pay or workload to raise?"
  • Day 60, ask the manager or client: "Is progress where you expected at this point?" Optional: "Is there support they need but haven't asked for?"
  • Day 90, ask the new hire: "What should change in the job description?" "Would you recommend this role to a friend?"
  • Day 90, ask the manager or client: "What should the next search for this role do differently?"
  • Notes and next action (each check-in): Who follows up, on what, and by when

Fill in the notes line during or right after each call, since it records who owns each follow-up. For a remote hire, add a first week question about equipment and time zones, and compare the setup with remote onboarding steps.

How to use new hire feedback before the next search opens

What you hear in check-ins falls into three groups, and each one goes to a different person. Sorting it keeps a role problem from being treated as an onboarding problem.

  • Role description issues: The work differs from what the hiring process described, such as more travel or a different mix of tasks. These belong with you, since the fix is to update the job description and intake notes.
  • Onboarding issues: Setup, training, or access problems that make the first weeks harder. Pass these to the manager or HR, and use the onboarding checklist to confirm which steps were missed.
  • Manager relationship issues: Friction over expectations, communication, or management style. Share only what the new hire agreed to share, and bring in HR when the concern goes beyond a misunderstanding.

A single comment is worth noting, while the same comment from several hires is a reason to change something. Consider a pair of new hires in one role who both say at day 30 that the job involves more customer contact than described. The recruiter updates the job description and intake notes, so the next candidates hear about that work early. If someone leaves anyway, an exit interview can show whether the issues raised earlier were the ones that mattered.

Search for the role as it turned out to be

Book a demo

Handling feedback carefully

New hires share more when they know how their answers will be used. At the start, explain who will see their responses, such as a manager hearing a summary of setup issues but not their exact words.

Don't promise confidentiality you can't keep. If someone raises harassment, discrimination, or a safety concern, pass it to HR under the employer's process rather than resolving it in a check-in. Tell the new hire that's what you're doing.

Start the first check-in before the first week ends

Check-ins show how the role, onboarding, and working relationship look once someone is doing the job, which interviews can't. Asking both sides on a set schedule, then sorting the answers, turns them into changes for the job description or the next intake. Set up a first week call for your most recent hire now, with the client's agreement if you work at an agency.

Start the next search with what you learned

Book a demo

Frequently asked questions

What is some good feedback to give a new hire?

Good feedback for a new hire refers to a specific piece of work and says what to keep doing or do differently next time. Positive feedback counts too, especially early on, when the person may not yet know which habits the team values.

Should a recruiter or HR run new hire check-ins?

That depends on the employer and the arrangement. A recruiter is well placed to ask whether the role matches what was described. HR and the hiring manager own onboarding and performance, so the check-ins can be split between them.

About the author

Mihailo Bozic
Mihailo Bozic

Founder & CEO @ Rotto

Founder & CEO of Rotto, building tools that help tech recruiters source better candidates, faster.

Related articles

How to Use AI in Your ATS
Recruiter Playbooks

How to Use AI in Your ATS

Use AI in your ATS without missing good candidates: start with features a recruiter reviews, then test ranking on a role you have already filled.

By Mihailo Bozic
B2B Technographic Data: A Practical Guide for Recruiters
Recruiter Playbooks

B2B Technographic Data: A Practical Guide for Recruiters

Learn what B2B technographic data shows, how providers collect it, and how recruiters can use it for business development, sourcing, and vetting providers.

By Mihailo Bozic
Candidate Data: What It Includes and How Recruiters Use It
Recruiter Playbooks

Candidate Data: What It Includes and How Recruiters Use It

Learn what candidate data includes, six practical ways to use it in recruiting, and how to keep your candidate records accurate, fair, and lawful.

By Mihailo Bozic
AI Recruiting: A Practical Guide for Recruiters
Hiring TrendsRecruiter Playbooks

AI Recruiting: A Practical Guide for Recruiters

AI recruiting explained for working recruiters: what AI does at each hiring stage, the risks, the U.S. rules to know, and how to start safely.

By Mihailo Bozic
9-Box Grid: What It Is, How to Run One, and What It Means for Hiring
Recruiter Playbooks

9-Box Grid: What It Is, How to Run One, and What It Means for Hiring

Learn what a 9-box grid is, what each box means, how to run a fair 9-box talent review, and how to turn the gaps it shows into a hiring plan.

By Mihailo Bozic
Campus Recruiting: How to Plan a Season That Ends in Hires
Recruiter Playbooks

Campus Recruiting: How to Plan a Season That Ends in Hires

Plan campus recruiting from school choice to start date: pick schools, set offer deadlines schools accept, track intern conversion, and know agency rules.

By Mihailo Bozic
Rotto

Built for recruiters who work from a brief, not a boolean.

rotto.com