Retained Search vs Contingency Search: Which Fits the Role

For hiring teams choosing a search firm and agency recruiters deciding how to price a search

A woman in her 50s compares two printed documents beside a laptop at a sunlit café table

Retained search means the employer pays a search firm part of its fee before anyone is hired, and one firm generally works the role. In contingency recruiting, an agency is paid only when its candidate is hired, and several agencies can work one role. This guide is for hiring teams choosing a firm and for agency recruiters deciding how to price a search.

Retained search vs contingency search at a glance

FeatureRetained searchContingency search
How the firm is paidA retainer billed in installments as the search movesOne fee when its candidate is hired
Paid if nobody is hiredYes, since the retainer is non-refundableNo
ExclusivityUsually one firm holds the searchSeveral agencies can work the same role
Who carries the riskMostly the employerThe recruiting firm
Roles it fitsSenior executive and leadership rolesEarly career to mid-level roles
Before sourcing startsStakeholder calls with key leadersUsually no stakeholder calls
Search speedSlower start that builds toward a slateA much faster search process
Terms to put in writingPayment schedule plus guarantee and off-limits termsFee plus guarantee and candidate ownership terms

Source: SHRM's 2016 explainer, SHRM's 2021 interview, SHRM's 2022 Q&A, AESC, Carnegie Mellon University and Colorado State University

What each option does

Contingency and retained deals aren't the same thing: they're two different ways to pay an outside recruiter for a hire.

In retained recruitment, the employer pays a firm up front to run the search. Its main strength is thoroughness: a search firm partner told SHRM in 2021 that a more thorough retained search is better suited to C-suite and leadership roles.

The trade-off is timing, since the employer pays before seeing any results. Pairing the firm with a clear executive search strategy on your side keeps that early spend aimed at the right slate. Agree up front on what a strong slate looks like, so the firm and your team judge it the same way.

Contingency recruiting gives the employer two clear strengths: no fee without a hire, and speed. In the same 2021 SHRM interview, the partner said contingency is the way to go for fast turnaround on early career positions.

The trade-off is attention: the partner added that contingency recruiters normally have many more job orders on their desks. Ask how many open roles the recruiter is working before you brief them. If you brief more than one agency, give each the same written brief and one contact for feedback, so every candidate faces the same bar.

How fees and payment terms compare

A retained firm bills part of its fee before anyone is hired, and a contingency firm bills only when its candidate is hired. One practitioner told SHRM in 2022 that retained firms charge 30 to 35 percent of total compensation and contingent search 20 to 25 percent. Treat those as one practitioner's figures, since your agreement with the firm sets the real fee.

The same practitioner said retained firms bill one-third at the start, another third when a slate is presented, and the last third at hire. Carnegie Mellon's HR office says retained payments are often made in three equal installments.

The same Q&A says contingency puts 100 percent of the risk in identifying and qualifying candidates on the recruiting firm. A retainer shifts most of the risk to the employer, who is committed to paying two-thirds of the fee with or without a hire. For an agency, a retainer pays for research time up front, while on contingency that research is unpaid risk.

How commitment and exclusivity compare

A retainer generally gives the search to one firm. On contingency, SHRM's 2016 explainer notes that a client may hire several contingent recruiters for the same job. Several agencies widen your reach, but they can send you the same person twice. If the search is confidential, consider keeping it with one firm so fewer outsiders hear about it.

For the agency, contingency means competing with other agencies for the same placement. Deep research on a role you may not fill is a gamble, so match your effort to your odds. Confirm each candidate's interest and permission before you submit, so your submission holds up if another agency sends the same person.

AESC's client bill, from the body that represents retained firms, says the terms of an engagement should be in writing. It lists fees and payment schedule, deliverables, guarantees, and off-limits, meaning the companies the firm agrees not to recruit from. For contingency, add a candidate ownership rule: who earns the fee when two agencies, or your own team, submit the same person, and how long a submission counts. Build these clauses into a staffing agency contract template, and have counsel review the final agreement.

How speed compares, and what a slow start costs

Contingency moves faster, while a retained search starts slower and goes deeper. A retained recruiter can spend several days with key stakeholders before the search begins, the partner told SHRM in 2021. For a leadership hire, the slow start costs days before sourcing begins but buys alignment on what the role needs. If you're the hiring team, line up your stakeholders' time early so those calls don't stretch the start further.

On the contingent side, the same interview says the search process is much faster. For an agency, a slow start there can cost the placement. When other agencies hold the same role, the first strong, interested candidate in front of the client can decide who gets paid.

On a retainer billed in thirds, a slow slate also pushes back the installment that comes due when the slate is presented. Either way, the agency gains from building a strong shortlist sooner.

Agency recruiters: build the shortlist faster

Book a demo

Pick the model by the role in front of you and which side of the deal you're on.

If you're hiring:

  • Leadership role: for the C-suite, a board seat, or another leadership hire, use a retainer, and use one when you're replacing someone quietly.
  • Early career or mid-level role: with plenty of active candidates and a deadline, use contingency agencies.
  • Several similar openings: use contingency with a short panel of agencies and a written candidate ownership rule, especially when your own team is sourcing too.

If you're the agency:

  • Leadership search: ask for a retainer, since the research time comes first and the client gets exclusivity.
  • Fast-moving role: take it on contingency when your network can present strong candidates quickly.
  • Crowded role: if the client has already briefed several agencies, ask for a period of exclusivity before you invest deep research time.
  • Client pitch: lead with the model that fits the role, which is a core part of recruiting business development.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a retained search cost?

It's a percentage of the hire's pay, so the base matters as much as the rate. Colorado State's policy says a retained fee is based on the anticipated salary, while contingency firms generally take a percentage of first-year total cash compensation. On a role with a large bonus, that difference changes the fee, so ask which pay your agreement counts, including bonus and signing bonus. For an agency quoting a fee, stating the base up front can head off a dispute at invoice time.

Can I use both?

Yes, across different roles, with a retained firm for a leadership hire and contingency agencies for volume roles. Don't add agencies to a role a retained firm holds exclusively unless your written agreement allows it. If you run both, keep each role's terms in its own written agreement.

What does a retainer pay for?

It pays for the whole search, not just the names at the end. Carnegie Mellon's HR office says executive search firms provide end-to-end recruitment and staffing services. AESC, which represents retained firms, says its members give expert advice from the beginning to the conclusion of each assignment. Ask the firm to list what that covers as deliverables in your agreement.

What happens if the new hire leaves early?

That depends on the guarantee in your agreement with the firm. Guarantees are one of the terms AESC says belong in a written agreement. Ask what the remedy is, such as a replacement search or a credit, how long it lasts, and what voids it. For an agency, the same terms define how much replacement work a placement can trigger.

About the author

Mihailo Bozic
Mihailo Bozic

Founder & CEO @ Rotto

Founder & CEO of Rotto, building tools that help tech recruiters source better candidates, faster.

Related articles

Rotto

Built for recruiters who work from a brief, not a boolean.

rotto.com