Predictive Index Assessment: How to Use PI in Hiring

What a PI pattern tells you about fit for a role, and where leaning on it creates fairness risk

A man in his 40s reads a printed assessment report at a glass-walled meeting room table with a laptop open beside him

The Predictive Index assessment is two separate hiring tools: a Behavioral Assessment of workplace drives and a timed Cognitive Assessment of reasoning.

Your candidates will ask how to prepare for the predictive index test, but you decide what the results mean for a hire. Used well, the results sharpen interviews, but one timed score used badly can decide who you never meet.

Key takeaways

  • The Behavioral Assessment measures four drives and isn't pass/fail.
  • The Cognitive Assessment is a short timed test of reasoning.
  • Define what the role needs before you look at any results.
  • Treat the timed score as one input, and offer accommodations up front.

What the predictive index assessment includes

It's two separate tools from The Predictive Index (PI): the Behavioral Assessment and the Cognitive Assessment. Employers can use either one or both, and each answers a different question about a candidate. The behavioral side shows how someone is wired to work. The cognitive side shows how well they learn, adapt, and solve problems.

Both can sit alongside other pre-employment assessments you already run, such as work samples. PI results add the most when they sit inside a wider process with other evidence.

The behavioral assessment

The Predictive Index describes the PI Behavioral Assessment as a six-minute, untimed assessment of four drives: dominance, extraversion, patience, and formality. In the predictive index behavioral assessment, PI says candidates answer two questions about a single shared list of adjectives. The first asks them to pick adjectives for how they're expected to behave at work. The second asks for the adjectives they'd use to describe themselves.

The Predictive Index says it isn't pass/fail and there are no right or wrong answers. For you, that means there's no score to rank candidates by. High dominance isn't better than low dominance, since the result only shows whether a person's drives fit the role.

The 17 reference profiles

Every person who takes the PI Behavioral Assessment gets one of 17 Reference Profiles, which The Predictive Index calls a shorthand for how they're naturally wired to work. A profile name is a quick label for a whole pattern, and it helps you compare candidates at a glance.

It's still a label, so treat it as a starting point for interview questions. Two people with the same profile can bring very different experience and skills to the same role.

The cognitive assessment

The Predictive Index describes the PI Cognitive Assessment as a 12-minute, 50-question timed test of a candidate's ability to learn, adapt, and solve problems. PI says the predictive index cognitive assessment covers three areas of general mental ability: verbal reasoning, numerical reasoning, and abstract reasoning.

Unlike the behavioral side, this one produces a score, and the clock is part of the test. That makes it tempting to use as a quick screen, which is where fairness starts to matter.

Say you're filling a financial analyst role and a warehouse role in the same month. Complex reasoning carries far more weight in the first job, so one cutoff for both wouldn't fit either.

How to read predictive index results

Read a behavioral pattern by where each factor sits against the midpoint, then read all four factors together. The Predictive Index says factors left of the midpoint show a low amount of that drive, and factors to the right show more. PI's support guidance adds that the further a factor sits from the midpoint, the more forceful its behaviors will be.

Don't judge one factor on its own. High dominance with low patience can look different on the job from high dominance with high patience. Look at the shape of the whole pattern before you draw conclusions.

For the cognitive result, compare the score with what the role demands, not with the top score in your pool. A high score matters less when the job doesn't call for heavy problem-solving.

How to use the results in hiring

Employers look for a match between a candidate's results and what the role needs, set before you see any candidate. The Predictive Index advises defining what a role needs and comparing candidates against it.

Build the target with the hiring manager or client from the work itself, such as how much pace and detail the job demands. If you set it after seeing results, you'll drift toward the candidate you already like.

ResultUse it toAvoid using it to
Behavioral patternPlan interview questions about fitReject a candidate on its own
Reference ProfileCompare patterns at a glanceLabel someone as right or wrong
Cognitive scoreAdd evidence for complex rolesApply one cutoff to every role

Check each gap before the interview

Turn each gap between a candidate's pattern and the role target into an interview question. Say the role needs steady follow-through on detailed work, and a candidate's pattern sits far from that. Ask for a specific time they handled detailed, repetitive work and how it turned out.

Score those answers on your interview rubric the same way you score other evidence. The Predictive Index itself says the assessment should be just one of many data points in a hiring decision.

Find candidates who fit the role you defined

Book a demo

Using the cognitive test fairly

Run the timed cognitive test as one input, matched to the role's complexity, with accommodations offered first. OPM's assessment guidance warns that cognitive ability tests typically produce larger racial and ethnic differences than other valid predictors of job performance.

The same guidance recommends combining these tests with other methods, such as interviews, to lower any potential adverse impact. Adverse impact means a hiring step screens out one group at a higher rate. OPM also says the more complex the job, the better these tests work. So set a cognitive requirement only where the job calls for it, and set it role by role.

Timing raises a separate risk under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The EEOC's applicant guidance notes a 30-minute timed test may pose a problem for someone whose learning disability requires more time. It also says an employer may tell all applicants the process includes a timed test, then ask about accommodations.

The Predictive Index says its tests support reasonable accommodations through the ADA, such as 18-minute and 24-minute variations of the assessment. Beyond timing, the EEOC's testing guidance says any test must be job related and fit the employer's purpose.

Limits of the predictive index assessment

The main limits of the Predictive Index assessment are that the behavioral result is self-report and the profile is shorthand. Candidates pick the adjectives themselves, so the pattern shows how they see their own work style.

A Reference Profile can't tell you about skills or track record, so it shouldn't replace a work sample. A fixed cognitive cutoff for every role also ignores the link between job complexity and test value.

The EEOC's testing guidance also says a test vendor's validity documentation may be helpful, but the employer is still responsible for making sure its tests are valid. If PI doesn't fit a role, compare other talent assessment tools that test the skill directly.

What to do before you send the first test

Write the role target with the hiring manager or client, then decide which results screen and which only guide interviews. Draft a short accommodation notice that goes out with every test link. With those pieces in place, you can explain how you made each call.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good score on the predictive index test?

There isn't one for the Behavioral Assessment, since The Predictive Index says it isn't pass/fail. A pattern isn't good or bad, because it either fits what a role needs or it doesn't. Read the cognitive score against the role's demands in the same way.

Can I take a predictive index test for free?

Individuals can. The Predictive Index's Behavioral Assessment page invites people to discover their profile for free. For hiring use, the same page points employers to its plans and pricing, so check the current terms with PI.

Should you use both assessments for every role?

No. Use the Behavioral Assessment where work style shapes success, and add the Cognitive Assessment only where the job's complexity justifies a timed test.

About the author

Mihailo Bozic
Mihailo Bozic

Founder & CEO @ Rotto

Founder & CEO of Rotto, building tools that help tech recruiters source better candidates, faster.

Related articles

AI Resume Screening: How to Use an AI Resume Screener Without Missing Good Candidates
Screening & Interviewing

AI Resume Screening: How to Use an AI Resume Screener Without Missing Good Candidates

Use AI resume screening without missing good people: give the screener criteria it can read, review its ranked list in three bands, and check who it drops.

By Mihailo Bozic
Attention to Detail Interview Questions: 12 to Ask
Screening & Interviewing

Attention to Detail Interview Questions: 12 to Ask

Attention to detail interview questions to ask candidates, examples of detail-oriented work, and short work-sample tests that check the skill directly.

By Mihailo Bozic
Caliper Assessment: How to Read Fit Scores in Hiring
Screening & Interviewing

Caliper Assessment: How to Read Fit Scores in Hiring

Caliper assessment guide for employers: what the Caliper Profile measures, how job model scores work, how to read results, and where the limits are.

By Mihailo Bozic
How to Improve Candidate Experience: A Recruiter's Plan
Screening & Interviewing

How to Improve Candidate Experience: A Recruiter's Plan

A recruiter's plan for candidate experience: why candidates disengage, how to keep them updated, and how to cut drop-off with scheduling automation.

By Mihailo Bozic
Automated Candidate Screening: How to Set Up Each Stage
Screening & Interviewing

Automated Candidate Screening: How to Set Up Each Stage

Automated candidate screening, set up stage by stage: what each step should decide, where a recruiter reviews before rejection, and how to test it.

By Mihailo Bozic
Background Verification Software: How to Choose and Use It
Screening & Interviewing

Background Verification Software: How to Choose and Use It

Choose background verification software that sends each required notice, matches records to the right person, and fits the checks each role needs.

By Mihailo Bozic
Rotto

Built for recruiters who work from a brief, not a boolean.

rotto.com